The quote "An action is right if it is what a virtuous agent would do in the same circumstances" comes from Rosalind Hursthouse, a contemporary philosopher best known for her contributions to virtue ethics. Born in 1943 in New Zealand, Hursthouse has significantly influenced moral philosophy by focusing on virtue ethics, a subfield that emphasizes character and virtue as key elements in ethical decision-making. Virtue ethics, rooted in the works of ancient philosophers like Aristotle, offers an alternative to other dominant approaches in Western ethics, such as utilitarianism and deontological ethics, which focus on the consequences of actions or adherence to moral rules, respectively.
Hursthouse's statement encapsulates the core principle of virtue ethics: ethical actions are those that would be undertaken by a virtuous individual under similar circumstances. This perspective shifts the focus from simply determining the rightness or wrongness of individual actions to evaluating the character of the person performing the action. In this context, "virtuous" refers to possessing moral virtues like honesty, courage, justice, and wisdom, which inform ethical actions.
By rooting ethical judgment in the concept of a virtuous agent, Hursthouse provides a more holistic approach to ethics. Instead of isolating specific actions or dilemmas, this approach considers the broader context of an individual's character and life experiences. For example, in a difficult ethical dilemma, asking what a virtuous person would do in the same situation brings into play the agent's virtues, such as empathy, foresight, and fairness, allowing for a more nuanced ethical evaluation than simply weighing outcomes or rules.
Hursthouse's viewpoint also emphasizes moral education and development, as becoming virtuous is seen as a lifelong endeavor. The focus is not just on making the right decisions in specific scenarios but on cultivating a virtuous character that will naturally lead to ethical actions across various contexts. This aligns with the Aristotelian notion of 'eudaimonia,' or flourishing, where virtue is integral to achieving a well-lived life.
Her ideas are elaborated in works such as "On Virtue Ethics," where she outlines her perspective on how virtue ethics should be formulated and how it stands in relation to other ethical theories. Hursthouse discusses how virtues are deeply connected to rationality, emotions, and social practices, offering a comprehensive framework for understanding ethics.
Overall, Rosalind Hursthouse's statement that "An action is right if it is what a virtuous agent would do in the same circumstances" provides a cornerstone for virtue ethics, offering an approach that values character and long-term moral development. This emphasis on virtue over individual actions or consequences has implications not just for ethical theory but also for practical ethics, moral education, and our understanding of what it means to live a good life.
Comments