Graham Harman is a contemporary philosopher who has contributed significantly to the development of object-oriented ontology (OOO), a school of thought that postulates a radically democratic view of objects in existence. His concept that "objects withdraw from all relations" is a cornerstone of this philosophy.
Harman's assertion suggests that objects—whether physical, conceptual, or otherwise—possess an inherent reality that is always more than any interaction or relation can fully express or exhaust. In simpler terms, every object holds a core essence that remains perpetually beyond the reach of direct knowledge or complete interaction with other objects, including humans.
This notion of withdrawal means that objects never fully disclose themselves to us or to each other. Every interaction or relationship captures only certain facets of an object while leaving the rest concealed. For instance, when a scientist studies a stone, they may uncover its weight, chemical composition, and history of formation, but the stone's existence is not limited to these aspects. There is an elusive, inexhaustible depth to the stone that escapes detection and description.
Harman's idea counters the traditional emphasis on either human consciousness or language as the central player in the philosophy of reality. Instead, object-oriented ontology places the things themselves at the center of study. It insists that objects do not exist merely for us or in their relations to us—or to any other objects—but have their own autonomy and agency.
The concept of withdrawal also has implications for how we understand causality and interaction among objects. If objects always withhold something of themselves, then the relations we observe are only the external effects of more profound realities taking place within each object. The full reality of any object is never exhausted by its relations or functions. This underlines a sense of mystery and depth to the universe that object-oriented ontology seeks to acknowledge and preserve.
Furthermore, Harman's perspective suggests a form of respect for the autonomy of objects, freeing them from being merely props in human drama or reducible to their uses or functions within any system of relations. It evokes a sense of the otherness and independence of everything that exists, whether it be a stone, a raindrop, an idea, or a work of art.
In conclusion, Graham Harman’s idea that "objects withdraw from all relations" is a philosophical position that grants objects a complete reality outside of their interactions, denying total accessibility to any form of knowing, whether it is human or otherwise. It portrays a universe where each entity harbors an infinite reserve, a hidden dimension that keeps it perpetually beyond the full grasp of relations, ensuring that the essence of objects remains an enigma, perpetually unattainable and elusive.
Comments