Ludwig Wittgenstein, an Austrian-British philosopher, made profound contributions to the philosophy of language, logic, and the philosophy of mind. His statement, "Ethics, if it is anything, is supernatural and our words will only express facts," reflects his complex views on the nature of ethics and the limitations of language. This statement can be unpacked by exploring Wittgenstein's philosophical perspectives:
The Nature of Ethics: Wittgenstein's view of ethics as "supernatural" suggests that he saw ethical values and judgments as lying outside the realm of the empirical world that can be described by facts. In his view, ethics is concerned with what is absolutely valuable or important, but this value cannot be captured by factual statements. This perspective aligns with his broader view that some dimensions of human life, like ethics, aesthetics, and religion, transcend the factual and are not subject to empirical verification or falsification.
Limitations of Language: Wittgenstein's work, particularly in his later philosophy, emphasized the limits of language. He believed that language is adept at describing facts about the world – things that can be empirically observed and stated clearly. However, when it comes to areas like ethics, language reaches its limits. Ethical statements, in his view, do not convey facts in the same way that empirical statements do; instead, they express something beyond what can be captured in factual language.
Expressivism in Ethics: Wittgenstein's statement can be interpreted as an early form of what later came to be known as "expressivism" in ethical theory. Expressivism suggests that ethical statements do not describe states of affairs or facts but rather express the speaker's attitudes, emotions, or prescriptions. According to this view, when we make ethical statements, we are not stating facts but are expressing our attitudes towards certain behaviors or situations.
Ethics as Transcendental: The idea of ethics being "supernatural" aligns with Wittgenstein's view that the most important aspects of human life are those that lie beyond the descriptive powers of language. For Wittgenstein, true ethical understanding is not about stating facts but involves a deeper, perhaps mystical, appreciation of the world and our place in it. This view reflects his belief in the ineffable – that which cannot be expressed in words but is nonetheless crucial to human life.
The Tractatus and the Limits of Expression: In his early work, "Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus," Wittgenstein famously concluded that "Whereof one cannot speak, thereof one must be silent." This encapsulates his view that language can only meaningfully discuss what can be empirically verified. Ethics, being outside the realm of empirical verification, is thus something we cannot speak meaningfully about in factual terms.
In summary, Ludwig Wittgenstein's statement about ethics being supernatural and beyond the expressive capacity of factual language reflects his deep engagement with the limits of language and the nature of ethical understanding. He viewed ethical statements as transcending the empirical realm, expressing attitudes or values rather than facts. This perspective is integral to understanding Wittgenstein's broader philosophical contributions, particularly his views on the philosophy of language and the nature of meaningful discourse.
Comments