Robert Brandom's statement, "Understanding is fundamentally a matter of being able to do certain things with concepts," offers a pragmatic view of the nature of understanding and cognition. Brandom, an American philosopher known for his work in the philosophy of language, logic, and philosophy of mind, emphasizes the functional and practical aspects of understanding, particularly how we use and manipulate concepts.
This perspective can be explored through several key points:
Conceptual Mastery as Central to Understanding: Brandom's view places conceptual mastery at the heart of understanding. To understand something means to be able to use and apply relevant concepts effectively. For instance, understanding physics isn't just about knowing facts or theories; it's about being able to apply concepts like force, energy, or gravity in various contexts.
Active Engagement with Concepts: The statement suggests that understanding is not passive. It involves an active engagement with concepts, which includes applying, questioning, and interrelating them. This active engagement is what distinguishes genuine understanding from mere rote learning.
Pragmatic Approach to Knowledge: Brandom's approach aligns with a pragmatic philosophy of language and mind. In this view, the meaning of concepts and words is rooted in their use. Understanding, then, is about being able to use concepts appropriately in different contexts, to reason with them, and to communicate effectively using them.
Understanding as a Skill: From Brandom's perspective, understanding can be seen as a skill or competence. It's about what you can do with what you know, not just what you know. This approach emphasizes abilities like critical thinking, problem-solving, and the application of knowledge in practical situations.
Social Dimension of Understanding: Brandom’s work, particularly his focus on inferentialism, suggests a social dimension to understanding. He argues that the meanings of our words and concepts are shaped in a social context, through our interactions with others. Thus, understanding is also about being able to navigate and contribute to these social practices of reasoning and communication.
Relation to Other Philosophical Traditions: This view of understanding has affinities with other philosophical traditions that emphasize the practical application of knowledge, such as the later work of Ludwig Wittgenstein and certain strands of American pragmatism.
In summary, Robert Brandom's view of understanding as fundamentally about the ability to do things with concepts offers a pragmatic and functional perspective on knowledge and cognition. It emphasizes the active, practical, and often social nature of understanding, focusing on the application and manipulation of concepts as central to what it means to truly understand something.
Comments